|
« Eteraz.org Launches Anti-Fundamentalist Fundraiser | Main | Cultural Barriers and the Importance of Personalities » February 20, 2007
"Tell the American people we need the U.S. Army here:"
An Interview with the Jundi Posted by Bill
As outlined in my analysis of the Military Transition Team (MiTT) mission, the story of the Iraqi Army in Fallujah is a mixed bag. The "Jundi" (Iraqi Army soldiers) are aggressive and some units are quite competent, but training is ongoing, the quality of their leadership varies, and logistical and pay issues significantly hamper operations. Observing some IAs on a mission and meeting with others at Forward Operating Base Castle in northeast Fallujah reinforced almost all of these assessments initially voiced by various Marine and Army MiTT members. The Jundi seem to enjoy soldiering and have a positive outlook, but don't feel that they have sufficient numbers to secure Fallujah. Most of their answers appeared forthright and relaxed until we spoke about missing pay, at which point they handled questions like skilled politicians. I also had to ask them about the identity of the insurgents several times. Even now, I'm uncertain whether their insufficient answers were the product of having a bad interpreter, hesitance to respond or the fact that they truly just don't know their enemy. A common complaint from Iraqis centers around equipment -- they want more, better, newer. In some cases this gripe has been reasonable, but often it's not. Iraqis seem to almost universally have a fascination with technology, overestimating its role vs. training in the much-admired effectiveness of the U.S. military. When looking through my pictures with one Iraqi, his eyes lit up and stared like a kid on Christmas when we came across a shot of an Amtrak turret. The Iraqi police were upset when they received brand new Glocks as sidearms, because they assumed (ironically and incorrectly) that the Berettas issued to Marines are superior weapons. And in this interview, an IA soldier complained about weathering mortar attacks without having mortars of their own with which to return fire (Nevermind that Jundi blindly lobbing mortars at mobile insurgent mortar teams in a heavily populated city is a bad idea). I ran into this fascination with and complaint about equipment over and over again during my interactions with Iraqi soldiers and cops, despite observing new Humvees and plentiful small arms. Technological bias and other issues aside, MiTT commander Major Pat Semon estimates that the Jundi are "very good" soldiers who work well when they have good leadership. Jabbar, Mohaned F. and Mohaned N. granted me an interview in their cramped barracks at FOB Castle, home to elements of the 1-2-1 Iraqi Army. Former Army MiTT Member Major Jorge Velasquez describes them - "especially the two Mohaneds" - as "very professional" and "intelligent" soldiers. Please note that our conversation was greatly hampered by a sub-par interpreter, and some of their responses have been necessarily truncated or clarified because of the terp's pidgin English. ** INDC: How long have you been a soldier? And where are you from? Mohaned F: "Two years, one month. I'm from far away, Nasiriyah." Jabbar: "Two years, four months." Mohaned N: "Three years." INDC: What motivated you to become a soldier? Mohaned F: "I want to prevent terrorist activity here. I want to build my country." Jabbar: "I want to help my country." Mohaned N: "I also want to help my country, and I need the money. I have to support my family." INDC: Who do you think the terrorists are, the insurgents who are fighting you? Mohaned F: "The terrorists want to damage my country and I want to bring my country back to the years long ago, before Saddam Hussein." INDC: But why are they fighting? Who are they? Mohaned F: "The terrorist wants control of the government, he wants the power." INDC: And how can the insurgency be stopped, in Fallujah, specifically? Mohaned F: "I am a soldier, I have many duties. We guard the base here, go on patrols and raid houses; we catch the terrorists and prevent them from putting down IEDs. This is my job here, to prevent terrorist activity." INDC: So you think the Iraqi Army can do it? Mohaned F: "Yes. But we need time." INDC: How much time? Mohaned F: "Maybe by next year. But we need more staff. New weapons and more staff." INDC: What do you guys think about the Iraqi police in Fallujah? Jabbar: "In the past, we didn't work together with the police. But now, something is different - we work with the police. The terrorists are attacking both of us, the police and the Iraqi Army. So we are the same. And now the police works with the Army and they sometimes give us good information. So, we work together well now." INDC: How long has that trust and cooperation been going on? Jabbar: "(Since) a month ago. We have the same target and we both want to build the future of my country." INDC: I've also heard that some local Fallujans distrust the Iraqi Army because you guys are from different parts of Iraq and many of you are Shia. Does that hamper your ability to operate in the city? Mohaned F: "If we don't trust another we'll lose battles ..." INDC: If you don't mind me asking, are you guys Shia, Sunni, what? [All are Shia] Mohaned F: "But some of our guys are Sunni, but they are on leave right now." INDC: "Does that cause any tension with the local Sunni population in Fallujah? I've heard about the tension between the two ... Mohaned N: "Everybody here is Iraqi. We don't like the state of affairs here (with terrorism and insecurity), so there is no difference between the Shia and Sunni." INDC: So once again, who do you think the terrorist insurgents are? Are they locals, are they from other countries? Jabbar: "He has just one target, he wants to attack everyone. So he does not care whether you are Sunni or Shia." INDC: Yes, but that's their target; who are the insurgents? Mohaned F: "We don't know who. The terrorist is very strong: he has mortars but we don't have the mortars to shoot him back. Another thing, when we leave to go home we don't have the military convoy. He has the power." INDC: Speaking of challenges, I've heard that the Iraqi Army has had some issues with pay, with Jundi not getting paid. Some have quit. Have you personally had problems getting paid? Mohaned F: "We don't know anything about that. You need to ask the Ministry of Defense in Baghdad." INDC: But have you personally received paychecks? Are you getting paid right now? Mohaned N: "We've met with the Division commander when he visited here two months ago, and he promised that he would fix it. And we wait." INDC: Does it hurt your motivation to go so long without pay? Mohaned N: "The Commander of the Division said he would fix it for everyone who did not get their pay. And we'll wait. He's fixed the pay of people who have gone the most time without pay, others he has not." INDC: Do you think you have enough troops to patrol the city and provide security? Are you full strength? Mohaned F: "We don't have enough soldiers to send regular patrols out here. So it's a very dangerous area and we need more soldiers, more patrols. We don't have enough manpower to conduct patrols every day. We have few." INDC: What do you think of the American presence here? How do you feel about the Americans, and has this feeling changed over time? Mohaned F: "We work well with them. The MiTT team teaches my soldiers something new every day. We have classes with them." Mohaned N: "I wish to keep the US here because it is good for us. We can learn new things every day, and if we work together a long time, it will be good for the Iraqi Army." Jabbar: "I want the US to stay a long time. We need weapons, we need training we want to work with the Americans for a very long time." INDC: How do you view Iraq's future? What do you think is going to happen here? Jabbar: "We have a good future." Mohaned N: "It will be good." INDC: OK, let me ask one more time: do you have any idea who the insurgents are? Who are the people you are fighting? Mohaned N: "In the past, some people work for Saddam Hussein, like his intelligence service or the Fedayeen Saddam. These people hate the new army because they can't join the new army. But we are different than them - we hate the terrorists, we hate these people. And we want to build our country." INDC: How did you feel about the execution of Saddam Hussein? Mohaned N: "He's been in custody for years so this was a long time coming. He hurt a lot of people." INDC: What would you tell the American people if you could tell them anything? Mohaned N: "Tell the American people we need the US Army here. We want to work with them for a longer time. And in the future we can say that we have built the Iraqi Army together." The others nodded approval. *** If you'd prefer to donate via check, please e-mail me and I'll provide you mailing instructions. Thank you for your support. Posted by Bill at February 20, 2007 03:06 PM | TrackBack (10) Trackback PingsTrackBack URL for this entry: Comments"Tell the American people we need the US Army here. We want to work with them for a longer time. And in the future we can say that we have built the Iraqi Army together." I am finding the American Congress to be oddly at odds with the concept of victory. Now many will say that is the will of the public, to lose a war, for it is not our war to win. I do not believe this, it is ours to lose. If we stick together, love our country, and continue to fight for freedom, we can not lose. War is horrible, any fight is, but freedom is what we fight for, together, for each other. God brings us to this battle, our souls enter with free will, our being is fragile, but nothing is more important than family. I fight because I love my family, and country, that we share. Posted by: Robert at February 20, 2007 06:16 PM We can not stick together--this has been clear for some time now with Red and Blue states. As for fighting for freedom and willing a war: whose freedom and how do yoju win a war when the country our guyhhs are dying in is busy killing each other. Now the Brits will announce major withdraw (not surge) tomorrow, which may mean even more men sent over to iraqa. It is nice for the Iraq soldiers to teloll us they need us but then it is iraq Sunnis and Shia killing each other. How long will they need us? (ps: I have served twice in the military) Posted by: david still at February 20, 2007 06:36 PM The Sunni-Shia divide is much less of an issue in Western Iraq. Posted by: Bill from INDC at February 20, 2007 06:38 PM These tactics will leave them reeling. We owe it to the troops to have their backs covered by beating the fifth column here at home. Posted by: Tood at February 20, 2007 07:37 PM What's wrong with your trackbacks? Afraid somebody might speak a little bit of TRUTH to your PROPAGANDA? Christ. You're nothing but a Bushco running dog. Wait, what's that I smell? *sniff*... Oh yeah: a BEDWETTING LAPDOG! Posted by: Jeff G at February 20, 2007 09:03 PM Then again, if leftists understood numbers, they would not be leftists. Posted by: Tood at February 20, 2007 10:35 PM Wait - Jeff G is posting satire.... OK, my apologies. Posted by: Tood at February 20, 2007 10:45 PM Bill hits the nail on the head, version 3.0 Posted by: Matt at February 20, 2007 11:55 PM The big takeaway: We can win, we just need more time. Pulling the plug is something very few actually want. We (troops in Iraq) may want to be home with our families but we want to see victory here. We never want to come back, but we don't want the price of admission for never coming back coming from snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. There is a system and a plan in place -- it just needs time to work. Great piece. Posted by: Matt at February 21, 2007 12:00 AM As for fighting for freedom and willing a war: whose freedom Anyone who wants it works for me. I'm not too picky about who its dispensed to. Posted by: Purple Avenger at February 21, 2007 12:51 AM WOW!!!... But, obviously you would rather rant. Posted by: kirk at February 21, 2007 01:53 AM What a beautiful interview. Thanks. The Iraqis are so steadfast. I love them. Posted by: Kip Watson at February 21, 2007 05:16 AM We are so close to a democratic Iraq now. Maybe a year, maybe more, I don't know, but the country is coming together. I don't think most Americans realize the effect of 30 years of totalitiarin rule, and that it is something that simply takes time to recover and build back up again. Great interview, if you are military please help ensure we stay until the job is done by signing the Appeal to Congress at AppealForCourage.org Posted by: Jason at February 21, 2007 06:29 AM Good comment, Jason. And, we have never been occupied and enslaved from without. The only way we may be defeated is from within. Anyone who has been in Europe can see the differences also. "30 years of totalitarian rule". Add to that 75 years of totalitarian rule by the USSR in Hungary, Poland, the balkans, etc. Posted by: Chief RZ at February 21, 2007 08:50 AM Jeff G. and his keyboard commandos on the left are cowards. They love to criticize policy, but don't have the Intelligence to formulate a legitimate opinion on their own. Move On .org and the MSM do their thinking for them. Posted by: Steve at February 21, 2007 09:27 AM FYI - Jeff G is writing satire. Posted by: Bill from INDC at February 21, 2007 10:19 AM great post! great interview! i'm going to link it at my site. Posted by: ric ottaiano at February 21, 2007 10:45 AM Bill, Great work. This thing would probably be over if we here in the US were all of the same mind about it. The split is feeding enemy morale, no question. It showed in the pre-war manifesto by OBL.
You can't satirize the left. You simply cannot do hyperbole of them. But be a masochist if you must; be mistaken for one of them. To satirize you need to exceed their fervor and sentiments and there's just no where farther out to go. Posted by: Dan S at February 21, 2007 11:12 AM Sure. BLAME THE VICTIM, DAN S! Posted by: Jeff G at February 21, 2007 11:24 AM Funny nobody thought of clicking the link on Jeff's name.... Posted by: gail at February 22, 2007 02:47 PM I believe in what you guy's are doing for the people in Iraq.,but not everyone will stand by your side. You are not alone,I say this to you all and take this to heart, I have a great church.Our prayers go out to you all for you safety and your return home. I believe the President was right in his effort to help freedom become a wonderful word to the people Posted by: Sandra Taylor at February 22, 2007 05:04 PM Keep up the great work, Bill. JEFF G IS TEH SUXOR!!1! Posted by: Good Lt at February 23, 2007 11:34 AM you are big liar people in Iraq and in arabic countries hate american people Posted by: Henna Mark at February 24, 2007 12:52 PM GOD hate YOU AND keep YOU ALL panic. Posted by: Norma Famenol at February 24, 2007 01:03 PM Hello, I want toserve in the Amarican Army Posted by: Urinjon at March 7, 2007 06:36 AM |
Feed Me, Seymour
bill *at* indcjournal *dot* com
Support Our Advertisers
Search
Archives
June 2008May 2008 April 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004
Extras
PDARSD Atom RSS 2.0 RSS 1.0
Credits
Our Blogroll
|