INDC Journal

« Viktor Yushchenko Poisoned | Main | "It will be a big oven for them." »

December 08, 2004
Mary Mapes, "struggling mightily to save her job[?]"

Posted by Bill

The CBS Producer rearranges deck chairs on the Titanic:

As the Memogate investigation appears to be winding down (the report is said to be set for release in days), it appears that Mary Mapes, the controversial producer behind the report that sparked the whole controversy, has been struggling mightily to save her job and her professional reputation.

Earlier in the scandal, before CBS had semi-admitted that its story was wrong, Mapes had been referring reporters to a bogus study by a Utah State University professor which claimed to support the authenticity of the documents CBS said were written by George Bush's former Texas Air National Guard supervisor.

Since CBS appointed a panel headed by the former head of the Associated Press and an ex-U.S. attorney general, Mapes has been acting very much to save her professional skin, writing up a 68-page statement in her own defense and repeatedly lobbying the commission to persuade it of her view that the documents which she obtained from a crackpot Texas Democrat could be true in spirit, if not in fact.

The "fake but accurate" defense is a close relative of the "chewbacca defense." The inherent irony is, it's revelatory for her to put so much effort into a 68-page report that's in her own self-interest, as opposed to putting any effort into fact-checking the original story that was constructed to smear a hated President. The mental contortions required to go to such lengths to deny culpability (including shopping for more fake expert analysis) indicate that she probably hasn't learned many lessons from the scandal. And probably never will.

UPDATE: My prediction? She gets fired from CBS and picks up a job at PBS within 60 days.

Posted by Bill at December 8, 2004 04:44 AM | TrackBack (3)

Comments

Mary Mapes was also instrumental into the staging the Abu Gharib (sp?) non-torture fiasco. That whole episode should be investigated as well.

Posted by: erp [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 06:51 AM

Abu Ghraib happened. She didn't stage anything. If you are referring to the excess coverage, that was out of her hands after they broke it, though I'm sure she was pleased.

There's nothing to investigate.

Posted by: Bill from INDC [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 07:02 AM

It would perhaps be instructive to find out how what was, after all, evidence, found its way into her hands. I'm sure it was one of the defense attorneys, but I think we deserve to have the full story.

Especially WHY the attorney would think of contacting her.

Posted by: Robert Crawford [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 07:41 AM

I don't follow your logic. It was a legitimate story, and that's how typically journalism works. Just because we don't like the story doesn't mean it's not news.

Posted by: Bill from INDC [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 07:52 AM

Bill sez: "My prediction? She gets fired from CBS and gets a job at PBS within 60 days."

She'll get fired all right, but do you really think any news organization (even PBS) is gonna touch her with a 10-foot pole after this?

I suspect that unless she's been banking those payroll dollars for a "rainy" day or she has some other skill then "producing", she'd better breakout the big shopping cart. Heh, maybe I'll see her down on "D" Street by the Federal Center Metro station.

Posted by: Bucky Katt [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 08:38 AM

but do you really think any news organization (even PBS) is gonna touch her with a 10-foot pole after this?

Yes.

Would you like to make a public wager? Say, $20,000?

Posted by: Bill from INDC [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 09:03 AM

Would you like to make a public wager? Say, $20,000?

Hell, no.

I'm not sure about the organization of PBS, but my gut says she'll land some sort of job with a 'public' station. Or maybe CNN? Or...hey, I'll be Chris Matthews could use a new producer...

Posted by: Noah D [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 09:31 AM

Heh..well you don't spend numerous hours writing up a 68 page essay to try and save your "professional reputation" if you think you have a hells bells of chance of being rehired by someone/anyone fairly quickly.

20 Grand is a bit rich..and I admit I could be wrong...but if you lay out something more reasonable for a working class slob, say loser pays for dinner at DC Chophouse and specify exact terms of the bet, I'll go for it.

Posted by: Bucky Katt [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 10:36 AM

This is on topic, and funny besides:
The Case of the Misbegotten Memos

Posted by: SeanGleeson [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 04:12 PM

Bill is actually probably correct.

Look at the case of April Oliver. She was the CNN producer who produced the "Operation Tailwind" special that charged that the US military had used nerve gas in Vietnam.

When her story turned to dust, and CNN fired her, she went on the lecture circuit, but AFAICT, has not found work again in the TV-journalism biz. (This is based on a few minutes' googling of her name, admittedly---none of which turned up anything more recent than 2002, in an anthology of essays.)

So, it would appear likely that, if CBS burns Mapes, she's probably done in the field.

Posted by: Sun-Tzu [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 05:03 PM

Actually, I think she'll end up working in academia. Mary Mapes: Professor of Journalism.

Nice, eh?

Posted by: Farmer Joe [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 8, 2004 09:29 PM

I love your prediction.

Well, I do not love it as much as I think it may be accurate, which is horrifying, actually. I stopped watching PBS after Bill Moyers went off the deep left end--she would fit in well there.

Posted by: liberator [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 9, 2004 01:34 AM

FWIW- Kevin Craver over at Rathergate.com had an interesting take. Mapes will be allowed to resign/retire with a generous severance package. One of his sources is saying that Mapes is negotiating a "big payoff" with CBS in order to avoid her publishing a "tell-all" book about CBS' "inner workings" ala Bernie Goldberg.

A potential win-win scenario here for Mary and certainly no shopping cart down by "D" street.
(rats!).

Posted by: Bucky Katt [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 9, 2004 09:55 AM