INDC Journal

« Another Manhattan Art Critic's Post | Main | The Next War is Already Here

(It's the Same War - UPDATED) »

November 16, 2004
Rice as SecState

Posted by Bill

I'm surprisingly detached about the appointment. Rice has stellar credentials and a strategic grasp of the the multi-generational asymmetric challenge of Islamofascism and WMD, but her reviews as NSA were generally mixed from a spectrum of sources, and I'm unclear of what her agenda will be at the head of State's massive beauracracy. Is she there to clean house of entrenched and rebellious liberal foreign service officers, or represent the President's top-line diplomatic agenda with more clarity? Both? Based on descriptions of her muted refereeing of National Security debates during Bush's first term, my gut wonders if her natural level of aggression is suited for the merciless work of reforming a government beauracracy. I'm certainly willing to give her the benefit of the doubt - we'll see. Dr. Rice's executive experience at the head of Stanford University should come in very handy.

Another interesting question is how Islamic countries will deal with a woman SecState at this pivotal time in the region's history that demands American engagement and brokerage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While it's certainly fun to crow about the in-your-face example of Western pluralism set by the gender of the United States' top diplomatic official, I wonder if Rice's public profile will present any minor practical impediments in the diplomatic process. Not that a scintilla of our decision-making should bow to Islamic sexism, but it's certainly a wrinkle worthy of curious consideration. Her appointment might also serve as subtle model for reform and inspiration among women in the Middle East; Al Jazeera has to cover a US SecState's visit to the region, and something tells me they won't be slapping a burhka on the good doctor.

Should be interesting. I wish her congratulations and good luck.

Posted by Bill at November 16, 2004 11:14 AM | TrackBack (5)

Comments

I wondered about the whole 'woman factor' as well. We'll have to wait and see how it plays out.

Posted by: epoh [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 01:11 PM

Iran, Iraq and Afghanistan are all old issues for this administration. Ms. Rice is an expert on all things Russian. Bush is a genius in that he sees that Putin is the next big threat and is putting someone in place who knows how to prepare for the threat. Putin took $ in Oil-for-Food, sided with Saddam and is repressing business and people in his country.

Posted by: Phillies fan [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 01:16 PM

You may be right about the importance of the Russian angle, but ...

Iran, Iraq and Afghanistan are all old issues for this administration.

... methinks you're crazy on that.

The relationship of the US with the Islamic world will be the defining foreign policy issue for a generation.

Posted by: Bill from INDC [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 01:20 PM

I admire her, but she's COLD. She exudes none of Bush's warmth, & comes off as a ruthlessly efficient bureaucrat.

On the other hand, the Tough Bitch is the only persona women have successfully used to obtain Head of State, because it overcomes the electorate's hesitancy to put a woman in charge of natl defense, which is why Hill will never be president, too much liberal baggage.

(Helen Clark, btw, is irrelevent)

Posted by: jeff [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 01:48 PM

The relationship of the US with the Islamic world will be the defining foreign policy issue for a generation.

Exactly. One of the things those nations/societies are going to have to learn to accept is that the voice of the United States can come from the mouth of an incredibly smart, powerful woman... one who might even be President some day.

(Well, we can hope.)

If they can learn that, then maybe there is hope for them.

Posted by: Russ [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 01:52 PM

I, however, have to disagree on the Russia angle. Russia's not so much of a threat as it is unabashedly interested in promoting its economic and regional security interests. Putin has shown incredible flexibility when it comes to cooperating with us, even in his own backyard, and even when what we want of him contradicts Russian foreign policy goals. Perhaps the best and most recent example of that is his surprising support for the US-Georgian position on Ajaria.

It's also worth mentioning that the US military received enormous help from Russia in setting up our military bases in Central Asia. We wouldn't have been able to get all our equipment and supplies in as quickly as we did without the use of their extensive rail system.

It certainly helps to have a Secretary of State who knows Russia because it is the major player in a large, and increasingly important, area of the world. Russia is on the periphery of our major area of concern and could potentially be an incredibly helpful ally--something that Condi could help make them. The next big threat? I just don't see them being more than an occasional pain in the ass (which they certainly are now from time to time).

Posted by: Nathan Hamm [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 01:53 PM

I'm actually quite in favor of the ha! deal with this! aspect of it. One woman I met in India had just been moved there from Saudi Arabia by the State Department. Why? the Saudis would regularly refuse to meet with a woman. Good luck trying to refuse to meed with Rice...

Posted by: Adrianne Truett [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 02:19 PM

You mean the Islamic countries were cool dealing with a black man for the past four years? Listen, we go with the person we think is best. (By "we" I mean the U.S.) The Islamic countries will have to deal with it. Used to be companies justified refusing to hire blacks on the ground that their customers wouldn't want to deal with them. I'm not saying the President couldn't legally make such a decision with his Sec of State. Of course he could. But a sensible President would say to himself, "F--- 'em if they can't take a joke."

Posted by: Attila [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 02:51 PM

The "woman" factor certainly didn't hurt Madeline Albright.

Ooops. Nevermind. That really isn't the best example, now is it?

Re: Rice running for office...
While professionally, she is fully qualified and would make a great president, methinks her marital status (single, no kids) might disqualify her in the minds of some Americans.

Posted by: azlibertarian [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 03:00 PM

I disagree, azlibertarian. I think the only way a woman is going to make it to the VP or Presidency is to come across as a strong, independant, no-nonsense, person. People don't generally equate motherhood with those things.

Posted by: epoh [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 04:13 PM

Have you all forgotten M. Albright who found out she was Jewish when she was tapped for Secretary of State. They had to deal with her, so they did.

As for burkhas, I don't think our military women in Saudi Arabia should be forced to sit in the back of cars and wear where robes.

It's ridiculous. If their women agree to this nonsense, it's their business. No reason we should buy into it too.

Posted by: erp [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 05:21 PM

As a former State officer, I'm concerned about her ability to tame the bureaucracy, too. That was something that Albright saw as far, far beneath her dignity. Her deputies shared the sentiment. If Rice gets herself some good deputies--preferably from outside of State--things might happen.

Adrianne: I probably know your friend, as I left Riyadh just a year ago. But I have to say that the women in my office had no problem meeting with Saudis at any time, including the most religious of the Imams. It's a matter of knowing how to do it. I was actually in New Delhi immediately before being assigned to Riyadh in late Sept. 2001. I infinitely prefer Riyadh to New Delhi as a place to work. You could actually get things done there, without running through the 9th Level of PC Hell.

Posted by: JFB [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 16, 2004 11:12 PM

Condi will be fine - if she can handle academic politics, she can handle State.

Posted by: BD [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 17, 2004 07:16 AM

The model for Condi at State is not the NSA but rather Stanford. I think the president viewed her job at NSA as a refereeing job, and that she did. Ceaning house at Stanford I think shows she can be tough with a disfunctional organisation.

Posted by: David [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 17, 2004 12:57 PM