INDCJournal: Clarifications on Heinz-Kerry's Effective Tax Rate <b><i>(UPDATED AGAIN)</i></b>

« Even More on ABC's Mark Halperin | Main | MTV Scaring Up the Vote (UPDATED - Rock the Vote is Overtly Partisan) »

October 16, 2004

Clarifications on Heinz-Kerry's Effective Tax Rate (UPDATED AGAIN)

Posted by Bill

Post deleted.

Why? Because I can, I'm out of my depth on these tax issues, and I don't want to put out inaccurate information until I get a better read on the situation.

I'll leave the relevant links about the Tides Foundation up for perusal.

Conservative accusations about the Heinz Foundation's charitable giving.

TruthOrFiction's assessment of the Heinz Foundation's charitable giving.

Factcheck.org's assessment of the Heinz Foundation's charitable giving.

I'm coming up on Pundit Review Radio in a minute, by the way.

UPDATE: Drudge now cites a Wall Street Journal article (no direct link), and that's good enough for me:

"But even this minimal disclosure deserves more attention in light of John Kerry's pledge to raise tax rates. In 2003, Mrs. Kerry -- or Teresa Heinz, as she declared herself on her IRS 1040 form -- earned $5.07 million, hardly a surprising income for someone estimated to be worth nearly $1 billion.

"The news is that $2.78 million of that income came in the form of tax- exempt interest from what the Kerry campaign's press release attributed to investments in 'state, municipal and public entity bonds.' What the campaign didn't say is that these are the kind of investments that rich people can afford to hire lawyers and accountants to steer their money into."

On her "remaining 'taxable' income of $2.29 million, Mrs. Kerry paid $627,150 in taxes, for an overall average federal tax rate of only 12.4% on her $5.07 million in total income." This "puts Mrs. Kerry's tax rate at well below that of other filers in her super-rich neighborhood. But it also means she is paying a lower average rate than nearly all middle- class taxpayers paid in 2001, the last year for which the IRS has published the data.

The top 50% of all federal filers contributed 96.1% of all federal income taxes in 2001, and they paid an average income-tax rate of 15.9%. That's 3.5-percentage points more than Mrs. Kerry paid in 2003." At the "very least, Mrs. Kerry's tax returns are a screaming illustration of the need for reform to make the tax code simpler and fairer. But they also show that Senator Kerry's proposed tax increases are much more about a revenue grab than they are about tax justice."

I'm still interested to learn if serious contortions are necessary to invest in "'state, municipal and public entity bonds," but her effective rate was 12.8%, and Drudge did not bury his original story. My mistake.

Posted by Bill at October 16, 2004 09:46 AM | TrackBack (0)