|
« The Boston Globe | Main | Taking the Fight to Mordor (UPDATED) » September 17, 2004
Huh?
Posted by Bill All due credit: thus far, the Washington Post has been doing a very fair, accurate and thorough job on the forgery story. But look at this piece on A5: Suspected CBS Source Is Well-Regarded Texan In adjacent Taylor County, which includes the city of Abilene, Burkett is viewed as an intelligent activist or statesman of sorts by Democratic officials -- the crusading voice against what is wrong with the Republican Party in general and with Bush in particular. Knowing what we already know about Burkett's ideology, personal animus for Bush and tendency to throw around unsubstantiated charges, I'm a bit taken aback by the tone of this article. Have they vetted Burkett's past quotes comparing Bush to Napolean and Adolf Hitler? Do they mention the fact that he has a serious axe to grind against George Bush regarding a chronic illness? Does it mention Burkett's quote that "we" have "reassembled" Bush's records? And do they interview any sources that have a different opinion of Burkett? I have very little doubt that such sources are abundant, and that some of them are Democrats; I'm basing this statement on some of my personal research. I'm sure that many locals have a high opinion of Burkett, and that many people agree with his views, but the paucity of dissenting opinion in that article is somewhat odd. UPDATE: And on the other end of the spectrum, Drudge headlines: CBS DOCUMENT 'SOURCE' COMPARED BUSH TO HITLER Which leads to this Houston Chronicle piece: Texan has a history of attacks on Bush Keep in mind, the WaPo's piece, the Chronicle's story and Drudge's take are all completely accurate; but why do we have to root around and piece together our news like we're working on a damn jigsaw puzzle? UPDATE: Here is a pretty thorough round-up on Burkett. Posted by Bill at September 17, 2004 01:22 PM | TrackBack (3) CommentsThe reason for the WaPo return to 'slant as usual' is because the topic is turning off of CBS specifically. At this point, the story is growing wider and could reflect badly upon Dems and Kerry (directly or indirectly). Given their normal bias, I suspect we will see more return to normalcy at the Post in further stories. Posted by: RadCap at September 17, 2004 02:13 PM Building him up as a "well respected Texan" is going to make it harder for them to say he was just a disgruntled, unstable, embittered "loose cannon" acting irresponsibly on his own if he is found to be the one who forged the documents. The more legitimate he is made out to be, the stronger the impression will be that the forgeries were spread with the knowledge of "legitimate" democrats. Posted by: gabe at September 17, 2004 02:14 PM Even though the Washington Post has sometimes done commendable things in their editorials and a few news stories, they still "are-what-they-are", a liberal MSM outlet. I think you have it right: as the forged memo story progresses, it has the potential to damage the Democrats and Senator Kerry, not just CBS News and Dan Rather. When the stakes are that high, the Post is compelled to move into damage control mode. Posted by: Jim Bender at September 17, 2004 02:17 PM Can anyone corroborate the Freepers' story that Col. Staudt mentioned in the memos called BS on the story? I think Ace has a link, but as yet nothing on ABCNews.com (Freepers reported hearing from him on ABC radio) Burn, baby, burn. I think I'll send my local CBS station manager a copy if this is true. Posted by: Brett at September 17, 2004 02:27 PM One of the funniest issues with the Boston Globe so far has been their FRONT PAGE HEADLINE over the story has been retracted. Instead of http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2004/09/15/for_the_record/ Posted by: globestar at September 17, 2004 02:43 PM I'm listening to 770 KTTH Seattle, I think they do ABC news on the hour, and I've heard _Major General_ Staudt (he was a Col _then_) say 'I never put that sort of pressure on anyone, I had no reason to do so'. I get the impression this was culled from a full interview somewhere - this was just the on-the-hour snippet. Posted by: Al at September 17, 2004 03:25 PM Hmmmm ... is THIS the guy that Rather refers to as an "unimpeachable" source? Surely a new definition. One suspects that there was an intermediary. Posted by: Kevin Murphy at September 17, 2004 03:48 PM News From the Local Paper, the Abilene (Texas) Reporter-News Media frenzy in Baird follows Guard report
Burkett, who lives about 10 miles south of Baird, surfaced Wednesday as the suspected source of controversial documents cited in CBS News reports that raised new questions about President Bush's Air National Guard Service in 1972-73. The Washington Post and other media reported that at least one of the documents bore the heading of the FedEx Kinko's Copies Abilene store, which is 21 miles from Burkett's rural Callahan County home. Visiting news reporters were commonly greeted with a blank stare followed by a ''Who?'' when they asked townspeople whether they knew anything about Burkett. No one answered the phone at Burkett's home when a reporter from the Abilene Reporter-News tried to call. Bill Hargrove, co-owner of the popular downtown eatery The Whistle Stop Cafe, said that, to his knowledge, ''I've never laid eyes on him.'' He said that all he knows about the documents in question was what he'd read in the newspaper ''I think he's stirred up a hornet's nest,'' Hargrove said. ''If he can back up what he says, fine. If not, he ought to stay out of it.'' Baird lawyer Bob McCool said he heard of the Burkett saga from an unusual source: his mother, a resident of suburban Philadelphia. ''What have you got in the water down there?'' Maureen McCool asked her son as a preface to informing him of the reported Abilene Kinko's link, he said. ''They're focused on the wrong war,'' said McCool, a Democrat who said he's not sure who will get his presidential vote in November. What's happening in Iraq today is far more important than what the presidential candidates were doing 30 to 35 years ago in the Air National Guard or the Navy, McCool said. Callahan County Sheriff Eddie Curtis said he had never heard of Burkett before the retired National Guard lieutenant colonel called him Wednesday afternoon to complain that media vehicles were parked ''on his place.'' ''Go up there and tell them to leave,'' Curtis said he advised Burkett. Burkett did just that, said Sylvia Moreno, a Washington Post reporter based in Austin. Callahan County Judge Roger Corn said he met Burkett and his wife, Nicki, when the couple came to the courthouse to do some official business several months ago. ''He and his wife came up and introduced themselves,'' Corn said. ''That's the only contact they've had with me.'' Corn said late Thursday afternoon that he'd been ''pretty busy'' and hadn't had a chance for much conversation with fellow citizens about Burkett. But reporters from The Washington Post, The New York Times and Newsweek magazine called to chat about him. On Thursday, as on Wednesday, several reporters and news photographers parked outside the locked iron gate of the Burkett ranch, hoping to get a long-range camera shot or an interview. But unlike in February, when Burkett came forward with a report that he had spotted aides to then-Gov. George W. Bush discarding documents from Bush's Air National Guard files, he was avoiding the media Wednesday and Thursday. Repeated phone calls by the Reporter-News were not returned or not answered, an experience shared by other reporters. David Van Os of San Antonio, Burkett's lawyer, said his client no longer trusts the media and does not intend to talk to any reporters. Van Os is running for Texas Supreme Court on the Democrat ticket. In February, Burkett said he spent one day almost nonstop interviewing with reporters for several major national media outlets. Meanwhile, news that at least one document central to a high-profile national controversy brought unaccustomed attention to the Abilene Kinko's Copies store. Local media also received a flurry of requests for help by national media representatives. A clerk working alone at the Kinko's counter Wednesday night was interrupted every few minutes by phone calls from the media inquiring about the article. ''I can't even get my job done,'' said the clerk, putting down the phone as she moved to help a customer. The clerk refused to give her name. She had to tell the callers she could not she could not comment on the story. She referred the Reporter-News to a company public relations representative. On Thursday, a FedEx Kinko's spokesman said customer privacy is ''of the utmost importance'' to the company. Someone transmitting a document to CBS News could have used a self-service fax machine, so a store employee would not necessarily have seen any particular document, said spokesman Howard Clabo. The clerk said the store does not keep records of customers who send faxes. Chatter about the news buzzed among customers, such as Ossie Rister, an Abilene High School graduate now living in Dallas. ''It's kind of amusing it would be sent from here, because I don't know of any ties that Bush has to Abilene,'' said Rister, a self-proclaimed Bush supporter. ''The irony of is that it's my hometown.'' One local TV station scrambled to meet the request for satellite feeds and other service to national media. ''It's been chaotic,'' said KTXS-TV (Channel 12, Cox Communications Channel 4) News Director Iain Munro. ''Since we have the only satellite truck west of Fort Worth, everybody wants to use it.'' Munro said television stations from around the country called looking for video to use for their newscasts. ''They're asking for us to feed them video from Kinko's, and also Burkett,'' he said. Tom Vodak, news director for both KRBC-TV (Channel 9, Cox Channel 5) and KTAB-TV (Channel 32, Cox Channel 10), had a much quieter day. ''The only call we've gotten today was from CNN,'' Vodak said. ''Neither CBS or NBC has called us, which is weird. I expected more.'' The Reporter-News received calls from The New York Times and The Washington Post looking for photographs of Burkett and the Kinko's store. ''I knew we were going to get these calls,'' said Robert Rogers, Reporter-News photo editor. ''It's like running a psychic hot line. I tell them what we have before they start talking. Everybody's looking for the same thing.''
Posted by: Winemaker at September 17, 2004 03:48 PM It's interesting that Burkett's lawyer is a well connected Dem operative in Texas, David Van Os, who is running for a spot on the Texas supreme court. I wonder what the odds are that Burkett can afford Os. Most likely Os is providing Burkett with free or heavily discounted representation for political reasons. I'd say that's a connection to the Dem party. Posted by: Another Thought at September 17, 2004 04:22 PM Let them call Bill Burkett "well-regarded." Then, if it is established that he's the forger, the appropriate headlines become: "Well-Regarded Democrat Forged Memos to Discredit President" Next question: Which other "well-regarded" Democrats helped him? Suits me fine. Posted by: david at September 17, 2004 04:27 PM Winemaker, is this legit? If so, it's g-r-e-a-t! Sylvia Moreno of the Washington Post says: 'For half a dozen years, Bill Burkett has lived a pretty uneventful life in this tiny West Texas town. He and his wife are regulars at the Whistle Stop Cafe, ordering bacon cheeseburgers with jalapenos and fries or the pork chop special on Mondays.' How can this be -- REGULARS at THE WHISTLE STOP CAFE -- when the Abilene (Texas) Reporter-News says: 'Bill Hargrove, co-owner of the popular downtown eatery The Whistle Stop Cafe, said that, to his knowledge, ''I've never laid eyes on him.'' ' Whistle me this and stop the presses--another case of fake journalism! Posted by: gabe at September 17, 2004 04:44 PM Another slant on Burkett's "creative memory", which I haven't seen anything on today ... Didn't he say he overheard someone telling someone else during a meeting in the guard office to purge Killian's records as they related to Bush. I'm sure I heard Bill Bennett on Hannity & Colmes last night report that the only other living person in the world who was privy to that conversation, I believe his name was Cohn, said no such exchangeever took place Posted by: Fred Daniels at September 18, 2004 12:04 AM |
Feed Me, Seymour
bill *at* indcjournal *dot* com
Support Our Advertisers
Search
Archives
June 2008May 2008 April 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004
Extras
PDARSD Atom RSS 2.0 RSS 1.0
Credits
Our Blogroll
|