INDC Journal

« A Note To Readers | Main | SoCal Readers »

July 25, 2004
LA Times Story On Bloggers (With a Fisking/Cuban Prostitution Bonus)

Posted by Bill

I looked for my cartoon on the LA Times web site, but all I found was this (the story with no graphics). During the course of reading the piece, I spotted this gem:

10 "Bush made no mention [in his attack on Castro for encouraging sex toursim] of the influx of prostitutes … expected in New York during the week of the Republican Convention."

Dave Pell, writing on electablog.com

My first thought was that this is one of the most predictable cases of selective anti-Bush nutbaggery that I've seen in some time. It assumes at least one of the following points:

A. Bush is somehow loosely associated with the influx of prostitutes?
B. That the same influx isn't happening in Boston for the Democratic National Convention (it is)
C. That by virtue of this fact, any Democrat or Republican that speaks out about a dehumanizing sex trade in Cuba is a hypocrite
D. Or that we have to laugh at tee-hee incongruities because they involve policy speeches, politicians and sex.

Of course, Mr. Pell is credentialed for the Democratic National Convention. No word on whether he's planning on using the services of a prostitute.

Then I realized that the LA Times may have chopped the quote and used the most incendiary post that they could find his site (like they did with my Kerry cartoon), in order to fulfill the narrative of the blogger story. So I checked out the full quote from his blog:

Sex Tourism
In what could turn out to be the biggest Spring Break boost in Cuba's history, President Bush offered an out of context misquote from a 14 year-old old Fidel Castro speech:

"The dictator welcomes sex tourism. Here's how he bragged about the industry. This is his quote: 'Cuba has the cleanest and most educated prostitutes in the world.'"

Bush made no mention of the influx of prostitutes (one hopes clean, educated is fine too) expected in New York during the week of the Republican Convention.

Not much different, but after scanning the rest of the site, I realized that it's a just a snarky, throwaway joke. Mr. Pell defends Castro's quote as "out-of-context" and then doesn't bother to provide the context, and takes a hee-hee cheap shot at Bush because he had the gall to speak out about Cuba's sex trade, which flourishes particularly well on the island as a result of Cuba's heavy economic dependence on foreign tourism and currency, coupled with the collapse of lucrative employment opportunities in more traditionally noble professions.

Nice cheap shot, buddy. Leave the semi-humorous faux-incongruencies sculpted to fulfill cheap joke narratives to Wonkette. Oh, also leave her the prostitution angle, will you? She's an expert.

I also spotted this snippet regarding the Berger case:

Would any voter really reconsider a voting choice because one of the candidates's advisors (and in Kerry's case, there are hundreds of them) was involved in something this odd? Probably not.

The selective cognition is killing me. Imagine if one of Bush's advisors (and in Bush's case, there are also hundreds of them) got busted stealing code word documents on the eve of a report designed to assign potentially politically destructive blame for the 9-11 attacks.

Do you really think that no one would care? Or that the media would bury the story? Or that Mr. Pell would blog about the matter as something to be merely regarded as "odd?"

Disturbingly selective cognition, I tell ya.

Posted by Bill at July 25, 2004 10:44 AM | TrackBack (2)

Comments

What would happen if one of the members in Bush's administration outted a undercover CIA operative?

Posted by: Ben at July 25, 2004 01:16 PM

Then, of course, we have the LA Times' thousand-word exculpation of Castro's Cuba.

According to Trumbull, who conducted field research in Cuba, prostitution boomed in the Caribbean nation after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, providing an important source of currency for the Cuban economy. Castro, who outlawed prostitution when he took power in 1959, initially had few resources to combat it. But beginning around 1996, Cuban authorities began to crack down on the practice.

Although prostitution still exists, Trumbull said, it is far less visible, and it would be inaccurate to say the government promotes it.

Even when Castro made the remarks, Trumbull said, he was not boasting about Cuba's prostitutes as sex workers.

"Castro was merely trying to emphasize some of the successes of the revolution by saying 'even our prostitutes our educated,' " Trumbull said. "Castro was trying to defend his revolution against negative publicity. He was in no way bragging about the opportunities for sex tourism on the island."

Never forget that Cuba is the left's baby. They point to it as evidence that leftist politics and policies work, while ignoring the debilitating poverty and oppressive totalitarian state.

"See? If everybody just gives up on the antiquated and outdated 'liberty' idea, we can live in a socialist utopia!"

Now, to be fair, including the line in a Presidential speech was a pretty dumb idea. It was funny, but it clouded the message. The message was that human trafficking is an atrocity. Instead, everybody's talking about whether it's good for whores to have book-learnin'.

Y'all wanna get back to the point, maybe?

The president, citing a Johns Hopkins University study, said the easing of travel restrictions to the island in the 1990s created "an influx of American and Canadian tourists," who "contributed to a sharp increase in child prostitution in Cuba."

"We have put a strategy in place to hasten the day when no Cuban child is exploited to finance a failed revolution and every Cuban citizen will live in freedom," said Mr. Bush.

Posted by: Jeff Harrell at July 25, 2004 01:18 PM

Ben -

What would happen if one of the members in Bush's administration outted a undercover CIA operative?

Last I checked, a holy ruckus was made over the matter. Of course, the fact that Ms. Plame put her face in vanity Fair and her husband has been subsequently discredited and outed as a liar haven't played out in quite the same way ...

Also, we don't even know the source of the leak yet, so it's difficult to asign blame.

Next?

Posted by: Bill from INDC at July 25, 2004 01:47 PM

Jeff -

The quote was indeed out-of-context, but equally out of context was Mr. pell's joke that made a strange weave out of the policy speech and the RNC. Thanks for the link.

Besides reading about the prostitutes in Cuba, I've talked to foreigners who live in DC and vacation there ... it's sort of a sex trade paradise, the Thailand of the western hemisphere. In the most innocuous form, it's almost become socially acceptable for women to become "girlfriends" of seasonal tourists that send them a little something-something throughout the year, and get laid when they drop in on the island.

In the more disturbing forms, little kids are easy targets for predators that can pay families more money for time with their kids than they can possibly earn in a year.

The systemic nature of it is a consequence of Cuba's socialist paradise, of course.

Leftists would say that our embargo creates the conditions, but I have a big problem with this line of reasoning (of course); since when should a country's economy soley be dependent on trade with the United States? We're maligned for pursuing business interests in every corner of the globe, yet maligned for embargoing Cuba - by the same people.

Posted by: Bill from INDC at July 25, 2004 02:18 PM

About number five on the quiz. I thought Patrick Belton was going for Oxblog?

Posted by: LF at July 25, 2004 09:55 PM

No one ever accused the LA times of accuracy.

Posted by: Bill from INDC at July 25, 2004 10:00 PM

Castro, did, in fact, state what was quoted by President Bush. If I recall correctly the question of prostitution was posed and he used that particular statement, charmingly as usual, to change the subject.

Prositution was and is so prvalent in Cuba that it even impacted the language. The term "jinetera" was born from the prevalence of protitution in Cuba. Derived from the word "jinete" which means "saddle".

Posted by: Val Prieto at July 26, 2004 08:53 AM