INDC Journal

« Hump-Day Pledge Drive Update | Main | Morning Chuckle »

July 01, 2004
Interactive Journalism Question for INDC Readers

Posted by Bill

It's not often that the mainstream media gives you the perspective of Iraqis that are actively rooting for the success of the new Iraq. So here's your chance:

If you could ask any question of ...

1. An Iraqi citizen living in the United States

2. An Iraqi government official

... what would it be? What are you curious about that you're not getting from the news?

Please leave your questions in the comments section.

PS - This is not a rhetorical exercise.

Posted by Bill at July 1, 2004 08:27 AM | TrackBack (0)

Comments

What would you say to those who claim you were better off under Saddam?

What has been the best change in you life in the last year? What is the biggest new challenge in your life in the last year?

Posted by: Eric Akawie at July 1, 2004 09:04 AM

How do you feel / what do you think when you see the American left actively supporting those that oppose a free Iraq?

Posted by: Erik at July 1, 2004 11:50 AM

For the Iraqi citizen living in the United States:

Did you support or oppose the concept of invading Iraq? Did you support or oppose its execution? What connections do you have to the old regime? The new regime?

For the Iraqi official:

How do you intend to handle elections in a country with no reliable census? How does the continued presence of American troops affect your country's sovereignty? Do you prioritize delivering security or freedom to the people of Iraq? How would you address the Kurds' continued demand for a semi-autonomous state? What should happen in Kirkuk?

That's just for starters.

Posted by: pennywit at July 1, 2004 12:15 PM

To forestall people who assume I'm rude, or biased in the questions I propose, I should note that I am always inclined to be skeptical. Whether a person is liberal or conservative, I often assume that a person in prominence a) needs to have his motives questioned and b) if he can't handle a few simple questions, he has no business in public life.

--|PW|--

Posted by: pennywit at July 1, 2004 12:27 PM

I didn't think your questions were that biased. Thanks.

Posted by: Bill from INDC Journal at July 1, 2004 12:38 PM

For the Iraqi in the US:(assuming that they are Muslim)

Would a secular, pluralistic, Iraq attract you to return home or have you made your decision to stay in the US? If so, how deeply do you intend to integrate into mainstream society?

Posted by: Formerly Dan at July 1, 2004 01:03 PM

For the Iraqi official:

How will you reconcile the rights and responsibilities of your faction (Shia, Sunni, Kurd, other) and tribe against the rights of the others?

Posted by: Formerly Dan at July 1, 2004 01:30 PM

For the Iraqi official:

How would you respond to some Iraqis' worry that the new government is more likely to embrace Sharia than the old Saddam government?

[Note: Saddam's government, in theory if not in practice, was secular and contained recognition for women's rights.]

Posted by: pennywit at July 1, 2004 01:42 PM

For the Iraqi official:

Do you see Iraq taking a path toward privatized enterprise and a market economy?

Posted by: pennywit at July 3, 2004 06:44 AM

If Saddam were still in power, and you could live in any country in the world, where would you live?

Or to keep it shorter:

Why are you in America?

Posted by: BloodSpite at July 5, 2004 09:20 AM

As you know, most of the world was opposed to U.S. intervention in Iraq.

Do you feel there was any merit to the arguments for respecting Iraqi sovereignty and not invading?

Posted by: Gordon at July 5, 2004 09:23 AM

Iraqi official: what steps do you plan to take to avoid the mistakes of the democratization models of eastern europe and latin america- ie, corruption, elitism, suppression of civil society, economic opportunity and capital availability limit to favored segments of society?

Posted by: Jane at July 5, 2004 03:09 PM

1. Currently there are a lot of reports (not just on INDC btw) that American-trained Iraqi troops are turning on the Coalition soldiers. How do you propose to deal with this problem?

2. How is it possible to create any sort of government with Baathist or pro-Baathist members - given that this is the same party that murdered and raped half the country?

3. Will you close the borders to prevent insurgents from entering the country?

4. How do you intend to deal with a nuclear-capable Iran? Are you hoping for an outside military strike to disable/destroy the reactor? Do you forsee a possible war? And if so, how will the mostly Shia citizens react to such an occurence?

5. The muslim extremism has been a curse on Arab nationalism over the past several decades. Everywhere sharia has been instituted in full it has led to utter ruin and a corrupt dictatorial regime. Your country is currently where Europe was when it was in the process of casting off the chains of King and Church during the Rennaisance, however, you do not have the catalyst that the rennaisance provided. No revolutionary ideas of spirit or thought. What can you do to change that?

Posted by: ballantrae at July 5, 2004 07:57 PM

Finally.

Who is going to determine the Constitution of your government. What will influence the decision, for example, John Locke was the main influence behind the American Constitution. What similiar influence do you have?

Will you use the American Constitution as a model, seeing as how it works? If not, why not?

(I've never been able to understand why everyone insists on "reinventing the wheel" when they have an excellent document that works on hand)

-ron

Posted by: ballantrae at July 5, 2004 08:00 PM

1. An Iraqi citizen living in the United States

Exactly when is Iraqi-American Dearborn, MI "community" going to field their own storied 442nd RCT?

2. An Iraqi government official

So, what's its gonna take to raise an Iraqi Arab Legion, something we could use for our mutual and transnational interests?

Posted by: Eric at July 6, 2004 02:54 AM

1. To the Iraqi in the US:

Do you believe the Iraqi government is doing all it can to stabilize and unify the country so that you may one day soon return?

2. To the Iraqi government official:

Do you have any short or medium term goals to establish a peaceful, diplomatic relationship with Israel?

Posted by: El Jefe at July 6, 2004 10:41 AM

Same question for both notional people:

What will you do if Saddam walks?

Posted by: Chris of Dangerous Logic at July 6, 2004 01:15 PM

For the Iraqi official:
1) Which will happen first -- DC voters get to vote for representation in congress or Iraqi's get to vote for a representative in their national congress?

2) Is this important to you?

Posted by: fred at July 8, 2004 03:55 PM